Page 214 - ibdaa
P. 214
213 -b<¡~9¡EH -bJxF *]+(°*
+b~zD* ~|D*
_DH&*H i*4b~¦pD* gD A 6bF* F(* e¡gD* bsJ4b- i*2]pE ¤A ÉK jE xF* cm- J ° y£pgD* D3 ¦+
£A ~7 ° bEH ¡gE 8bs~7&* ]£Cb& gDb+ cgC e¡gD* tJ4bgD* E *K x£jC *& *wG ¤JH ibE¡D* *¡m~6 JwD* 2*xA&°*
JH]- fJx: dFb/ ¢D(* Ix1&* bBK x: bG &* bC tJ4bgD* bm~6 ¤gD* f£sJ4bgD* ibFb£cD* E x£j+ xjC*& ibFb£+ bG *&
bK cDb=H £gE *¡FbC JwD*H q£-bD* ¦+ bD *¡Cx- JwD* 8bs~7°& * ¢< ]g- hD*5 bE ¤~9bDb+ bgAxE DH tJ4bgD*
Jx~6bsD* *¡~z£DH 4bD* ¤A Jy)bD* G *¡FbC bE
i*¡' c- DwCH f£DbsD* eb0&°* b+*( £<]cD* 8bs~7É& D bK ~8HH ¤~9bD* < ,4¡~8 ¡14'¡D* ]J bE ,2b<H
E E'¡JH fgD* x£= iÉm~zD* ¤A i*xjD* ]~z+ u4¡' D* ¡J bGH ¤~9bD* E ,]g~zE ib/bgg~6* ¢< ¡- cg~zDb+
]J]/ E sJH ¤~9bD* $b+ ]£J u4¡' DbA *]+(°* £A ¢mgJ ¥wD* ~9¡D* ¡G *wGH f£<¡~9¡EH f£+ D3 J &*
¦+ 2¡/H E bE ]0 ¢D*( f£B2 ¡- b£0&°* ¦+ ¤A bD bK )*2 f£B2 h~z£D hFbC *( H f£<*]+*( f£< cDb+ wGH
b& 1 x£~zgD* ¡J fjDb. bK Fb£0*& H ££D* ¦+ ~¦g- hFbC *( H )bG 9¡= bgJ Ix1*& bFb£0*& H ~{D* ¦+ H&* i*xjD*
f£sJ4b- f£0 *& ~{gF &* ¡D&bD* x£= E z£A Ix1°& * ¡- ,xD* hc. ]B ¡J b& sD* &° 22x- H2 E *wG ¡F pFH
k£0 f£<*]+(°* f£D* E $y/ 2xmE bK ~¦J&* *wGH tJ4bgD* q£g+ bgG°* dc~6 bD x~zJ *wGH fp£p~8 x£= ÉK A hFbC bE
ibFb£+ b~{gC* $*x/ z£DH ,]J]/ i*x£~z- $*x/ ,]J]mD* 4bA°& * ]D¡g- ]BH fjJ]pD* ibFb£cD* E bK cDb= ,]J]/ bE sDQ
,2b<(* (* bK )*2 DwC z£D xE°& * bC *( H b-b+b~6 E fB2H f£<¡~9¡E xjC&* ,]J]mD* i*x£~zgD* - ¡- *& E&bFH ,]J]/
¤sJ4bgD* y£pgD* Lord Butterfield ]£Axg+ 24¡D b<2 bE *wGH fG¡~{E B°& * ¢< H*& ,y£pgE ¡- *& J tJ4bgD* $b+
"f£J¡D*"H f£sJ4bgD* i*y£pgD*
Historical and Whiggist Biases
,4bc< ]sg~6*H f£sJ4bgD* iÉ£pgD* $*x/*( ¤A ¡14'¡D* b/*¡J ¤gD* ib+¡~|D* b< "]£Axg+" 24¡D ~8H
-Whiggist- f£J¡D* i*x£~zgD ,2]pE ,]J]< fjE*& ex~9 DH (Gould, 1991) ]D¡= D3 ~8H bC "¤sJ4bgD* y£pgD*"
x1%* |s~7 ¥&* H*& u4¡' D* &* ¢+ y£p- ¡G £<¡D* JwG ÉC (* "¤J¡D* y£pgD*" q~|E ]sg~6* £< $b+H ¤~9bD
Jx~8bE qDb~|D E ~{+ $b1°& * xp- ¤DbgDb+H f£-*wD* £B bK E]sg~zE ¤~9bD* ¢< pJ
££J¡D* a2bc+ ]+ b£A hAx< a2bcD z~6&* 4*x0&°* eyp+ ]+ b£A x< rÉ~8É( D ]J'¡E J]B ¤FbJx+ ey0 ¡G Whig (1)
i*x£~zgD* (* bc~zpD* ¤A l*]0°& * - fE5&* b£~6H "x~|D* rH4" w1*& É1 E °*( f£sJ4bgD* l*]0°& * A J °H
*]+°( * ¤A ÉK A l]pJ bE *wGH f£B2 x£= H*& ,y£pgE ¡- ]B f£)bcD* bg£c:H bgDb~8&* ¤A f£<*]+(°* f£sJ4bgD*
~|Q A ]BH Ix1&* ¢D(* fc0 EH Ix1&* ¢D(* f<¡mE E Jbcg-H ¡g- £D* D f£B i*3 $b£~7&* lbcF* ¢D(* ¥2¡' J k£0
"4ÉE"kp+bC malevolent ]BbpD* H*& 4b~¦D* *]+(ÉD ~7bF ¤A *K x1¡' E ,xD* wG 4¡~{E x£= BbA4H"¤+HxC"
*]+(°* E D* dFbmD ~zF bmD* ¤A (Mclaren, 1993)
b~|J &* E ¤sJ4bgD* *]+°( * ¢< pD ]+° Fb& + Ix- bG°H*& ¤sJ4bgD* £pgD* 2]~|+ bgE bgDb~64 bJ]D 3(*
qc~|F *& bF4H]+ ¡J A ¤sJ4bgD* ¡pgD* b£~6 ¤A bFbE IxFH b-*y£p-H b£+ xF *& g~zF D *3(bA f)bA fJb+
64]F bE]< bc~zpD* ¤A D3 x£= &* bC bK £sJ4b- b£~zD* w1&* E ]+° F&* Ix- bg£Fb.H ¤~9bD* ¢< J]£/ bK Eb0
¤~9bD* ¤A h.]0 ¤gD* f£<*]+(°* b<&°*