Page 223 - ibdaa

Ÿ-b<¡~9¡EH Ÿ-bJxƒF ˆ*]+(°* 222

‡+b~zD* –~|ŒD*

¤A ,y£˜gE ibE¡cD*& f.É. obgF*( ¢D*( Jx€D* Ÿ+ hžgF* fB¡c~zE x£= fc1b~8 f£<*]+*( f+¡F $b›.*& ¤ŒA ÉK ž~6 "ÉJ*2" Jx: œ’J ™D "
¤gD* "—H4 ]F&* ”HxD*" ¢£~6¡˜+ ŸDb~|-* 2b<&* ™. "$*x~7 ¢•< $*x~7H" " ™B4 ¤/4bsD* Jx€D* ¢D*( ,2¡<"H "h£cD* ¢D*( ,2¡†D*" ¤G *K xž~7

œ< ŸDɏg~6* œ•<&* ]A Ÿ•£/ ¢£~6¡E f‰•+ l]pgJ *& ¤A Ÿ›E fc=4H The Beetles bžgJ¡£0H zAb›sD* fBxA fBb€+ ŸŒ‰~{D fm£gFH Ÿ+bc~7 ¤A bž~64bE

¢£~6¡E i*ym›˜D *K ]J]/ *K 4b£†E hpc~8&* &* b£~6¡E hjcD bEH šb< Newport Folk b/xžE ¤A f£)b+xž’D* i°°% * —b˜†g~6b+ ¤c†~{D* œŒD*
" Hw0 HwpJH ŸŒ•1 x£~zJ *& d0&* b›A –C ¤A b~¦K J&* –+ zAb›sD* fBxA “D3 ¤A b˜+ A ŸJx~8b†E ¤A z£D ix.&* k£p+ ”HxD*

~8H ]A Ÿ•˜< ¤A ¦Bb›g•D b0K x~7 "ÉJ*2" š]B ¤<*]+(* –˜< i*H2*& ¡’- ]B f££~6¡˜D* i°°% * &b+ Ÿp£~9¡- ¢•< ,HÉ<H
]£•g+ ¤Œg’- *& A ‡£€g~z- ° “F(*" ]C&* Ÿ›’D Woody Guthrie "¥x-¡= ¥2HH" ¤c†~{D* b›ŒD* x.*& bž~zŒF f•+b˜D* ¤A
x~7b†D* –~|ŒD* ¤A ¦Bb›gD* *wžD 9x†F Ž¡~6H "Ÿ+ xE bE –’+ xQ ˜- &* “£•†A |s~{D* “D3 —b˜<&* dp- h›C *3b( A bE |M s~7

‡+x˜D*

bG])*¡AH ,xcsD* fŒ•C

Costs and Benefits of Expertise

i*3 ¤GH bŒK £jC ÉK 1*]- –1*]g- ™žgAx†E (* –+ d~zpA f•)bG ibE¡•†E ¡’•˜J ° ™žA f†~6*H f£Ax†E ]<*¡+ $*xcsD* ‡g˜gJ

¢•< H&* ibE¡•†˜D* ‡E f<x~z+ –Eb†gD* ™G]0*& 4H]˜+ qc~|J k£p+ f£D°% bC f›£†E f£Ax†E i*4bžE ™žD xA¡J b˜E ,]J]< ib€+*x-
]/¡- k£0 b£K ExG bž˜£ƒ›- ¡’J ]BH b£K Db< bK ˜£ƒ›- f˜ƒ›E $*xcsD* fAx†E &* b˜C Ÿ~|~|s- –1*2 œE "ib£€†˜D* ‡E" –B&°*
¢•< *xK £jC $*xcsD* ‘¡ŒgJ ]BH —bm˜Db+ f~8b1 ,xcsD* &* „0° Ÿ•Œ~6*& ¤A f~6¡~zpE ibE¡•†EH šxžD* f˜B ¤A ,2xmE ibE¡•†E

4¡~{›E x£= welling Š›£DH |~|sgD* “D3 o4b1 z£D œ’DH ™ž-b~8b~|g1* i°bmE ¤A œJ]mg~z˜D* ¦†+
f<b~6 Ž°%* ,x~{< œE exJ bE ¢D*( ¡/bgpJ $*xcsD* ™ƒ†E *& (Simon & Chase, 1977 ) "y£~{-H ¡˜Jb~6" xC3H
¤A ¡£)b•- $*xc1 ]/¡J ° " ŸF&* *]g†J b˜GH ,y£˜g˜D* ,xcsD* wGH ]E&°* f•J¡: f•Eb†D* ,xC*wD* œE ˜›D* *wG *H4¡€J ¤’D

b˜+ fDb0 ¥&* %°* ¢g0 –m~z- ™D ŸF*& H]cJH ¢DH°& * f/4]D* œE ¡›gE °H ¡£)b•- ¡›gE ]/¡J ° ]£C&bgDb+H nFx€~{D* fc†D
fŒj’˜D* fC4b~{˜D* œE ]< œE –B&* ¤A b-(°* I¡g~zE ¢D(* bE |s~7 bž£A –~8H (Bobby Fischer) x~{g£A ¤+¡+ “D3 ¤A
‡B*¡E ¤A •˜pJ ¡GH f<b~6 D&* œ£~z˜1 ¢D(* Ž°%* ,x~{< œE ¤~¦˜J ]B 6x˜g˜D* d<ÉD* &* bEK ¡˜< 4]U F œpFH fc†•D* wG ¤A
Ÿc~{- ibBH&°* wG b( A 6x˜g˜D* d<ÉD fc~z›Db+H f<b~6 Ž°%* f~z˜1 ¢D(* D*& œE obgpJ ¥2b†D* d<ÉD* *& H nFx€~{D* 4bm0*&
"xjC&* H&* ,2xŒE D&* œ£~z˜1 ¡Ax†J œJwD*H ]~7xD* f•0xE bž£A *¡‰•cJ ¢g0 ,$*xD* ™•†- ¤A ¡˜•†g˜D* bž£~¦˜J ¤gD* ibBH&°*
¡’J &* ‡B¡gF b›Fb( A ™•†g•D fE5ÉD* f£›EyD* fEypD* ¤G nFx€~{D* ¢•< e4]g•D chunk f£›EyD* fEypD* hFbC *3(bA

fc†•D* wG ¤A f•.b˜E i*2xŒE —H°& * 5*x€D* œE 6x˜g˜D* nFx€~{D* d<° I]D
x£’ŒgD* ‚b˜F*& ¦†+ yJy†- bžF&b~7 œE ¤gD* –J]†g•D f•+bD* iÉ£j˜gD* (Ericsson, 2003b) ¡~z’J4*( ~8H ]DH
,]Eb/ h~z£DH £’g•D f•+bB ¤žA –J]†g•D f•+bB fJx€+ “D3 –†Œ- bž›’DH ‡B*¡D*H fE¡•†˜D* œE ÉK C –˜~{- bžF*& ]g<*H ¤<*]+°( *
"¡~z’J4(*" ~8H b˜C iɒ~{˜•D f£<*]+(°* —¡•pD* ¤A ,]£ŒE —bpD* f†£c€+ ¤G ¤gD* fFHx˜D* œE bK <¡F q£g- “Dw+ ¤GH fg+b. H&*
‡E f<x~z+ £’g-H rbm›+ ,]J]mD* B*¡˜D* ibc•€gE ¤c•- f˜˜†E ,4bžE ¡G x£csD* $*2*& xG¡/ &* £C" 8

¤<*]+(°* x£’ŒgD* 5y†J *& œ’˜J £’gD* *wG (* ",x£‰g˜D* ŽHxƒD*
° bK Fb£0*& ™žF*& f/4]D ,]£/ fAx†E ™ž•0 ¡Ax†J $*xcsDbA ,]†˜D* fAx†˜D* z~6&* œ< ™m›- f•˜gpE fŒ•C ”b›G &* ]£+

*wGH fŒ•’E ¡’- &* œ’˜J ib~9*xgA°* wG œ’D bž0x: ¢•< ™Gx£= 'HxmJ ° ib~9*xgA* ¡0x€J –+ –£~8bŒgD* ¢D*( ¡gŒg•J

°H ]J]/ 4¡ƒ›˜+ ‡g˜gJ Ÿ›’DH ]J]/ –0 ¢D(* –pD* o4b1 œE $¥]gcE |s~7 n•J ]A f£›ž˜D* f£~{EbžD* ˆ¡£~7 dc~6 x~zŒJ
¤A ,xcsD* xA*¡- š]< œE *H2bŒg~6* ]B ™Gx£=H "]JHxA"H "Ÿ£/b£+"H "œJH4*2" &* H]cJH $*xcsD* bž0x€J ¤gD* 4b’A°& * rx€J

*w’GH ¤D*¡gD* ¢•< ¤~zŒ›D* –£•pgD*H ¥4¡€gD* zŒ›D* ™•<H fJ4¡€gD* b£/¡D¡£cD* ¤<*]+*( –’~{+ bž£A *¡˜ž~6*& ¤gD* —¡pD*
])*¡A bžD &* b˜•jE bK ›˜. ,xcs•D &* q~¦gJ