Page 255 - ibdaa

Ÿ-b<¡~9¡EH Ÿ-bJxƒF ˆ*]+(°* 254

‡+b~zD* –~|ŒD*

‡+x˜D*

¤sJ4bgD* nž›˜D* ]F 4b-° bž›’D fŒ•gsE $b£~7*& Ixc’D* f£sJ4bgD* fB4bŒ˜D*

Different but Incomparable: The Great Historical Irony

i*$b›jg~6* ”b›G ‡c€Db+H Ix1&* eb0&b+ 4b- bE *4K 2bF ,2]p˜D* f£sJ4bgD* eb0°& * ¦†+ *& h˜•< bE *3(* &b/bŒg- ]B
œg~zJ*( H š°H (Kroeber, 1944, 1956) xJHxCH (Gray, 1966) ¥x=H (Bullough et al. 1980) ŸBbA4H ¡D¡+ –jE
xD* ¤A *]FÉ-¡’~6 ÉK jE ŸBbA4H "¡D¡+" 4bB ]A (Naroll et al. 1971) ŸBbA4H —H4bFH (Lamb & Easton, 1984)
œ£+ ibF4bEH x+HxC fJHb˜~zD* š*x/&°* ‡B*¡E œ£+ ibF4bE hJx/&* ™. x~{< zEbsD* xD* ¤A b£Db€J*( ‡E x~{< œEbjD*
e*x‰g~6°* “D3 dc~6H fA¡D&bE x£= ,x~7bc˜D* ibF4b˜D* *& e*x‰g~6°* x£jJ bE &* °(* œG¡C f£˜•†D* f£•˜†D* –0*xE
¤sJ4bgD* nž›˜D* fB4bŒE ¤G wGH ibAbjD* œ£+ 4bF *& °H f£sJ4bgD* eb0&°* œ£+ 4bF *& f£pD* ¤A —]†D* œE z£D ŸF&*

f£€›E h~z£D ibF4b˜D* œ’D fD¡ž~z+ bž£D*( Žx†gD* œ’˜J ibB4bŒ˜D*H i°¡pgDbA
f£<*]+(°* f£•˜†D* ¢•< i*H2&°* x.&* b›G xCwg›D fŒ•gsE eb0&* ¤A *¡•˜< œJwD* 6b›D* œ£+ 4 bF &* —]†D* œE z£D ŸF&* b˜C
*3bE –£Q s- œ’DH ,x£jE fDbEH bK +bgC ¤D*¡0 x~{F ¥wD* "]JHxA" ÉK jE w1 b£0&°* ¦†+ ¤A f˜žE i°¡p- h.]0&* £CH
d£~6*¡pD* ¤A 2¡/¡˜D* 8¡~|›D*H ib˜•’D* nDb†E H*& ¤FHxg’D°* $ÉE°* œ£†EÉD* œE *¡~zD H*& ŸD xA¡- ¡D –†ŒJ *& œ’˜J bC

šbJ&°* wG

b†K E fJ2xŒD* dG*¡˜D*H x~|†D* rH4 fŒ£;H ¡G 4¡ƒ›˜D* *wG œE ¤<*]+°( * –˜†D* b( A *w’GH

b& ~{+ •D*H f£<¡~9¡˜•D –~8¡gD* f+¡†~|C bK +b~6 aHb~z˜D* b›†/*4 ]BH f•£•B aHb~zEH ,x£jC bJ*yE ¤sJ4bgD* nž›˜•D *(
{Bb›- ™D ,]0*H fJ2H]pE ”b›GH f£sJ4bgD* f£c~z›D*H ,xž~{D*H f£/bgF°( bC fE]sg~z˜D* f£<¡~9¡˜D* i*x~7'¡˜D* f†£c:

š2bD* –~|ŒD* ¤A fD&b~z˜D* wG —Hb›gF Ž¡~6H ŠF*¡C f›£†E fAbj+ f~8bsD* 4b’A°& * ¤GH °&* –£~|ŒgDb+