Page 317 - ibdaa
P. 317

Ÿ-b<¡~9¡EH Ÿ-bJxƒF   ˆ*]+(°* 316

x~7b†D* –~|ŒD*     

                                  ‡+x˜D*

                            fDb~8&°* f£D]/

                                 The Controversy of Originality

  ,]JxA h~z£D bžF&* b˜+  “DwC ¡’- ° b˜+4 "Ÿ£+b~{- 2xmE ¡’- bE]›< bK 0 f•£~8&* f£<*]+°( * $b£~7&°* ¡’- *& œ’˜J –G
  fAbC bž£•< –˜g~{- ¤gD* ,]£0¡D* f£~8bsD* ¤G fDb~8&°* °& *xK ƒF  f˜žE fDb& ~zE  wGH  ‡B*¡D* ¤A ,2¡/¡E $b£~7&* Ÿc~{- ¤žA  ÉK †A
  *& dmJ bž›’D  f•£~8*& 2xmE œE xjC&* bFK b£0&* ¡’- b˜+4 bžF*& q£p~8  f•£~8*& ¡’- &* ]+ ° f£<*]+°( * $b£~7&°bA  ˆ*]+(°* ibŒJx†-
  ¤G –G  Warhol Campbell "–cEbC —H4*H" bž<xg1* ¤gD* $b~zpD* fc•< ¢D(*  ÉK jE  xƒF*  —*¡0°& * –C ¤A f•£~8*& ¡’-

                                                                          "f•£~8*& ¤G –G "bK 0 f£<*]+(*
  œE ™’A  f£<*]+(* f•£~8&°* iÉJH&bgD* œ’- ™D (bA  –JH&bgD* f£•˜< ¤A Ix1&* 4b’A°& fž+b~{˜D*H ,]J]mD* 4b’A°& * ˆ*]+*( œ˜’J ]B
  hFbC *3b( A "ÉK jE  "h•EbG" f£0x~zE h~9x< ,xE ™C f£<*]+(* x£=H f•£~8*& x£= ¡’g~6 ib£0x~z˜D*H šÉA&°*H f£F¡JyŒ•gD* 9Hx†D*
  f£F¡JyŒ•gD* šÉA°& *H 9Hx†D* fAbC ¢•< bž~zŒF fmpD* c€›-H  b£K <*]+*( bC ¥wD* ¡G A —H&°* 9x†D* (bA  f˜žE x£= iÉJH&bgD*
  b~9K x< *Hw1&bJ &* ¡G šÉA°& * ¡†Fb~8 bž•˜†g~zJ ¤gD* d£Db~6&°* ]0&*H  šÉA°& *H nE*xcD* 9x< ,2b<*( œE x£cC 2]< ”b›žA  fjJ]pD*
   Charlie's Angels; Dukes of Hazard; I,Spy “D3 ¢•< f•jE°& * œEH  *]K J]/ b˜K •£A Ÿ›E *¡†›~|JH b˜K J]B b£K F¡JyŒ•-
  ~{’g~zF Ž¡~6H "A f•£~8&°* ¤G –~z•~zE ¥*& ¤A f•0 —H*& –žA  b~¦K J*& iÉ~z•~z˜D* ¢•< fDb~8&°* —¡0 —¡D* c€›J ]BH   bGx£=H

                                              ebg’D* *wG œE x£1°& * –~|ŒD* ¤A –£~|ŒgD* œE ]Jy˜+ fD&b~z˜D*  wG

&*  ÉK jE  (Bryson, 1994) "¡~zJ*x+" Ix£A  fBx~6 ŸFb& CH H]cJ ]B 9*xgB°* ¦†+ *& ¡G ŸD ~6¡' J ¥wD* œ’D
                          ¡G Ÿ<*xg1* œE bžF&* ¢<2Q * ™.       šb< šÉA°& * 9x< b£/¡D¡›’- Ixg~7* "¡~zJ2&*"

                         ¤†£c€D* ™Db†D* ¤A x’A

                               CONSIDER THE NATURAL WORLD

bF¡<]- ¤gD* ib’£g’gD* œE 2]<  xE&°* f£0 ¤A  ”b›GH  ,x£jC b+K *¡+*& b›EbE*& qgŒ-H b›D f˜ž•E ¤žA  ‡)*4 $¤~7 f†£c€D*
 bž•J]†- H*& bž~9*xgB* œ’˜J ¤gD* 4b’A°& * H&* ,]£mD* Ÿ£+b~{gD* H&* šbžD(°* ”b›G ]mF *& b››’˜£A  f£†£c€D* —b˜<°& * ¤A xƒ›D* ¢D*(

h˜˜Q ~8 ]B  ÉK jE  fpŒ~|˜D* "H24bF¡£D" f+x†A  “£g’gD* *wG bE]sg~6* "”¡’~{g£G 2xŒD&*" H "¤~{›£A*2 H24bF¡£D " *& H]cJH
f£/4b1 fc: Ÿ•C *wG ¤˜p-H  fcCx˜D* iÉm< 4H]- ¤’D ˆ43°& * HxJ]J 8bs~7&*    ¢D*( h/bg0*H  ,bŒp•~zD* Ÿc~{J b˜+
–~|0H  ,xJ]g~zEH f˜<bF "H24bF¡£D" f+b+2 hFbC ]D  fjJ]pD* f+b+]Q D* 4¡žƒ+ `c›g˜D* ¡G ™£˜~|gD* *wG ¡’J “Dw+H fJ¡B
–˜†g~6*H   –~|ŒD* *wG ¤A bK 0° Ix1&°* Ÿ-b’£g’-H Ÿ-b<*xg1* œ< kJ]pD* –~|Q ŒF Ž¡~6H   ,bŒp•~zD* œE ,x’ŒD*  wG ¢•<

                 ŸD¡+ ™•ŒD* *wG ~8H ]A The Birds 4¡£€D*  ¤’£~6ɒD* Ÿ˜•A ¤A Ÿ-*3 “£g’gD* "”¡’~{g’£G"

  ¡˜•Q ~zJ 6b›D* –’A  Ÿ+ b˜K •~zE *xK E*& f†£c€D* xcg†J b›E ÉK C *& ]£ŒJ ¥wD* šb†D* ˆ¡~9¡˜D* œE ˆ¡F b~K6b~6&* ¡G  4¡£€D*  ™•ŒD* *wG ¤A  ]m- bE *(
  bžF¡~zcpJH bžF¡•C&bJH 4¡£€D* ¢•< 4b›D* ¡•€J  +b~zD* ¤A  6b›D* bC  b~zF(°* ¢•< eɏF°( b+ šbJ°& * œE bEK ¡J 4¡£€D* hEbB ¢g0  4¡£€D* 2¡/¡+
  kc< ]A  bž+ d<Ég- H*& f†£c€Db+ *]K +*& kc†- °  ™•ƒD* *wG ¢•< Ÿ£A 2x- ¥wD* š¡£D* $b/H b~zF(°* œE *xK £jC 4¡£€D* hFb< ]D  8bŒB&°* ¤A
  b˜K •~zE *xK E&*     š¡£F*4¡£D* bFxcg<* b›F&° “D3 l]0  kc†D* “D3 b›•~8H*& œJ*& ¢D(* xƒF*H  94&°* œE Ÿ/xsg~6*H      š¡£F*4¡£Db+ ÉK J¡: b~zF°( *
   (Schickel, 1973)  bž•C 4¡E&°* šbEy+ “~z˜- *&      H*&      šb< ibF*¡£pD* –’D rbgJ ]A ¥4]J œEH     x£jC Ÿ›’D  b_K £~7 ¥Hb~zJ ° ŸF(*  Ÿ+
   312   313   314   315   316   317   318   319   320   321   322