Page 317 - ibdaa
P. 317
-b<¡~9¡EH -bJxF *]+(°* 316
x~7bD* ~|D*
+xD*
fDb~8&°* f£D]/
The Controversy of Originality
,]JxA h~z£D bF&* b+ DwC ¡- ° b+4 "£+b~{- 2xmE ¡- bE]< bK 0 f£~8&* f£<*]+°( * $b£~7&°* ¡- *& J G
fAbC b£< g~{- ¤gD* ,]£0¡D* f£~8bsD* ¤G fDb~8&°* °& *xK F fE fDb& ~zE wGH B*¡D* ¤A ,2¡/¡E $b£~7&* c~{- ¤A ÉK A
*& dmJ bD f£~8*& 2xmE E xjC&* bFK b£0&* ¡- b+4 bF*& q£p~8 f£~8*& ¡- &* ]+ ° f£<*]+°( * $b£~7&°bA *]+(°* ibJx-
¤G G Warhol Campbell "cEbC H4*H" b<xg1* ¤gD* $b~zpD* fc< ¢D(* ÉK jE xF* *¡0°& * C ¤A f£~8*& ¡-
"f£~8*& ¤G G "bK 0 f£<*]+(*
E A f£<*]+(* f£~8&°* iÉJH&bgD* - D (bA JH&bgD* f£< ¤A Ix1&* 4bA°& f+b~{D*H ,]J]mD* 4bA°& * *]+*( J ]B
hFbC *3b( A "ÉK jE "hEbG" f£0x~zE h~9x< ,xE C f£<*]+(* x£=H f£~8*& x£= ¡g~6 ib£0x~zD*H ÉA&°*H f£F¡JygD* 9HxD*
f£F¡JygD* ÉA°& *H 9HxD* fAbC ¢< b~zF fmpD* c-H b£K <*]+*( bC ¥wD* ¡G A H&°* 9xD* (bA fE x£= iÉJH&bgD*
b~9K x< *Hw1&bJ &* ¡G ÉA°& * ¡Fb~8 bg~zJ ¤gD* d£Db~6&°* ]0&*H ÉA°& *H nE*xcD* 9x< ,2b<*( E x£cC 2]< bA fjJ]pD*
Charlie's Angels; Dukes of Hazard; I,Spy D3 ¢< fjE°& * EH *]K J]/ bK £A E *¡~|JH bK J]B b£K F¡Jy-
~{g~zF ¡~6H "A f£~8&°* ¤G ~z~zE ¥*& ¤A f0 H*& A b~¦K J*& iÉ~z~zD* ¢< fDb~8&°* ¡0 ¡D* cJ ]BH bGx£=H
ebgD* *wG E x£1°& * ~|D* ¤A £~|gD* E ]Jy+ fD&b~zD* wG
&* ÉK jE (Bryson, 1994) "¡~zJ*x+" Ix£A fBx~6 Fb& CH H]cJ ]B 9*xgB°* ¦+ *& ¡G D ~6¡' J ¥wD* D
¡G <*xg1* E bF&* ¢<2Q * . b< ÉA°& * 9x< b£/¡D¡- Ixg~7* "¡~zJ2&*"
¤£cD* DbD* ¤A xA
CONSIDER THE NATURAL WORLD
bF¡<]- ¤gD* ib£ggD* E 2]< xE&°* f£0 ¤A bGH ,x£jC b+K *¡+*& bEbE*& qg-H bD fE ¤A )*4 $¤~7 f£cD*
bJ]- H*& b~9*xgB* J ¤gD* 4bA°& * H&* ,]£mD* £+b~{gD* H&* bD(°* bG ]mF *& b£A f££cD* b<°& * ¤A xD* ¢D*(
hQ ~8 ]B ÉK jE fp~|D* "H24bF¡£D" f+xA £ggD* *wG bE]sg~6* "¡~{g£G 2xD&*" H "¤~{£A*2 H24bF¡£D " *& H]cJH
f£/4b1 fc: C *wG ¤p-H fcCxD* iÉm< 4H]- ¤D 43°& * HxJ]J 8bs~7&* ¢D*( h/bg0*H ,bp~zD* c~{J b+
~|0H ,xJ]g~zEH f<bF "H24bF¡£D" f+b+2 hFbC ]D fjJ]pD* f+b+]Q D* 4¡+ `cgD* ¡G £~|gD* *wG ¡J Dw+H fJ¡B
g~6*H ~|D* *wG ¤A bK 0° Ix1&°* -b£g-H -b<*xg1* < kJ]pD* ~|Q F ¡~6H ,bp~zD* E ,xD* wG ¢<
D¡+ D* *wG ~8H ]A The Birds 4¡£D* ¤£~6ÉD* A ¤A -*3 £ggD* "¡~{g£G"
¡Q ~zJ 6bD* A + bK ~zE *xK E*& f£cD* xcgJ bE ÉK C *& ]£J ¥wD* bD* ¡~9¡D* E ¡F b~K6b~6&* ¡G 4¡£D* D* *wG ¤A ]m- bE *(
bF¡~zcpJH bF¡C&bJH 4¡£D* ¢< 4bD* ¡J +b~zD* ¤A 6bD* bC b~zF(°* ¢< eÉF°( b+ bJ°& * E bEK ¡J 4¡£D* hEbB ¢g0 4¡£D* 2¡/¡+
kc< ]A b+ d<Ég- H*& f£cDb+ *]K +*& kc- ° D* *wG ¢< £A 2x- ¥wD* ¡£D* $b/H b~zF(°* E *xK £jC 4¡£D* hFb< ]D 8bB&°* ¤A
bK ~zE *xK E&* ¡£F*4¡£D* bFxcg<* bF&° D3 l]0 kcD* D3 b~8H*& J*& ¢D(* xF*H 94&°* E /xsg~6*H ¡£F*4¡£Db+ ÉK J¡: b~zF°( *
(Schickel, 1973) bC 4¡E&°* bEy+ ~z- *& H*& b< ibF*¡£pD* D rbgJ ]A ¥4]J EH x£jC D b_K £~7 ¥Hb~zJ ° F(* +