Page 322 - ibdaa

321 Ÿ-b<¡~9¡EH Ÿ-bJxƒF ˆ*]+(°*
x~7b†D* –~|ŒD*

œ£Œ•gs˜D* 8bs~7°& * ¢•< fŒ•gsE i*x£.&b- xŒ~z•D &* “~7 °H i*4b£sD*H šÉ0&°* ib˜G¡- ¥*& "fŒ£s˜D* fcJx‰D* 4b’A°& *"
f€=b~9 ,x£0 2xmE œJx1*% ]›< ¡’J ]BH ™žg£†B*H ¢D(* œJx1%* b~8K bs~7*& ]£†J b˜›£+ 6b›D* ¦†+ ]›< ˆ*]+(°* –žQ ~zJ ]A

œ£Eb£›+" bž+ $b/ ¤gD* fJ4¡jD* 4b’A°& * ¢D(* fž/ œE 4b~7&* ]A b›G f£sJ4b- fJxs~6 2¡/¡+ "Ž¡’D]£E" x†~7 ]D
f£†B*HH f£•˜< Ix1&* fž/ œE hFbC 4b’A&°* wG *& £CH –£~8&°*H ]J]mD* ¤~6b£~zD* šbƒ›D* —bmE ¤A Hx1%*H "œ£•’F*xA
¡•†ŒJ œJwD* ™G ¡˜DbpD* b˜F(* i*4¡. ¡.]pJ ° ¡£•˜†D* —b/xD*H b£K •˜< ÉK /4 "œ£•’F*xA" bC" ŸD¡+ “D3 œ< xcQ <H *]K /
f£’JxE&°* ,4¡jD* ibJxs~6 I]0(* ¢D*( ŸDb†A&* x£~{-H œJx1°% * œ££’JxE&°* œ£JÉE ‡E bJK 4¡. "œ£•’F*xA" qc~8&* “D3 ‡EH “D3
‡B*¡D* 94&* ¢•< ¡~{£†J œ££•˜< 8bs~7&* fc†~|D* ,b£pD* )bpD ™ž-b£0 *¡~6xC 8bs~7&* fAb. ¤A bG42b~|E ]/¡- k£0
4bg1* q•€~|E ¡GH "šb†D* €›˜D*" ™~6b+ fJ4¡:*xcEÉD ™ž-*$°H œ< šb< *¡•s- 8bs~7*& Ÿ~zŒF "œ£•’F*xA" –†A b˜C
*& ¤GH Ix1&* fB4bŒE ¢D*( bF2¡J *wGH b’JxE*& —ɏg~6* qDb~|D x£c’D* 4b†~{D bFK *¡›< Thomas Paine "œJb+ 6bE¡."
x£= bFK ¡›/ 4bcg<b+ ™ž†~|£~6 Ÿ-*3 ¡G bC šb< œ££’JxE°& * œE x£jCH "œJb+ 6bE¡." ]›< bEK b< bK €›E H]cJ bC bE

8 "i*¡›~6 x~{†+ hB¡D* “D3 –cB ¤Fɏ<

bC b˜A –B°& * ¢•< ¤~zŒ›D* 4¡ƒ›˜D* œE f~{Bb›˜•D f•+bB f£FbjD* fB4bŒ˜D* —¡0 wG "Ž¡’D]£E" xƒF fž/H *(
x~|†D* rH4 ¢•< *]K £/ °K bjE ]Q †- f£’JxE°& * ,4¡jD* *& “~7 °H zestiest x~|†D* rHxD 9*x†g~6* 2xmE ¡G b›G Ÿ0x: —HbpJ

f›£†E f£›E5 i*xgA ¤A °K b˜g0* xjC&* ¡’- i*4b’g+°* ¦†+ &* £CH

$b£~7&°bA ˆ*]+°( * œ< œpF ŸAx†F bE ‡E bEK b˜- f~zgE ¤žA œ£J4¡jD* 8bs~7°& * f£†B*¡+ f•†g˜D* f£FbjD* fB4bŒ˜D* bE*&
hB¡D* ¤A bž›’DH ,]J]/ bžF*& ¢•< H*& f£+4b-H fJ]<bc- bžF&* ¢•< bFK b£0*& bž£D(* xƒ›JH b†K E f£†B*¡D*H fDb~8&°b+ ~|g- f£<*]+(°*
bcK Jx= z£DH b£K £0 b£K <*]+*( ÉK ˜< –j˜J 3(* Hx1%°* ¡J4¡jD*H "œ£•’F*xA" Ÿ•†A bE (bA *w’GH œG*xD* ‡~9¡˜•D fc~6b›E Ÿ-*3

Ÿ-*3 hB¡D* ¤A *]K / ,]£ŒEH f£•˜< bG¡~z~6*& ¤gD* f£:*x˜J]D* fJ4¡ž˜mD* ,])bA ¡’- *&

fJ2xA ‘HxA 2¡/H x1%*H œ£0 œ£+ b›D 9x†J ebg’D* *wžA b›D f_/bŒE h~z£D xŒ~zD* f£˜G&* —¡0 f˜)bD* f£D]mD* wG (*
ˆ*]+°( * d•€gE b›G xCwg- &* œ’˜JH ,x£jC f£<*]+*( ib~6*42 b~¦K J&* xA¡- bE *wGH 4¡E&ÉD fJ2xA iÉJHb& - bž›E x£jC z’†J
bž›£†+ ,]0*H f_£+ ]/¡- ° ŸF*& ”b›G ,x’ŒD* hFbC k£0 zEbsD* –~|ŒD* ¤A Ÿg_£+H |s~{D* œ£+ –<bŒgDb+ Ÿ£D(* bFx~7*& ¥wD*
,x’ŒD* wG (* –+ xŒ~zD* ¢•< b†K c: Ÿ-*3 $¤~{D* c€›JH ˆ]c˜D* 2xŒD* ¢•< ]˜g†J Ÿ•C “D3 *& 3*( Ÿ.H]0 £†- H&* ˆ*]+(°* x~Qz£-

ibBH&°* ¦†+ ¤A 8bs~7&°* ¦†+ —b˜<&°* ¦†+ d~6b›-H b›G bGbF2x~6 ¤gD* ib’£g’gD* fAbC ¢•< c€›-

ib~9*xgA°* f~{Bb›E

QUESTION ASSUMPTIONS

¦†cD 6b›D* ¦†+ ‡E qm›- ib’£g’gD* ¦†+ *& œE ™=xDb+ ŸF*& bž›£+ œE ,x£jC *K 4b€1&* Ÿ-b£: œ£+ 4b’A&°* ¦Bb›- –˜pJ
]A ]0*¡D* š¡£D* ¤A i*xE ,]<H b£K E¡J “Dw+ š¡J b›E –’A ib~9*xgA°* rx: ¢D(* 6b›D* –C œ£+ bEK b< ÉK £E ”b›G * °Q *( hB¡D*
–cg~z˜Db+ '¡c›gD* ¢•< ,4]D* “J]D ¡’- *& ¤G “D3 œE ]C&bg•D ,]£0¡D* fJx€D* *& ‡E *]K = ‡•€- Ž¡~6 z˜~{D* &* 9xgŒ-
hF*& H ”xpgJ ™D ,4b£~zD* –m~zE x~7'¡E *& 9xgŒ- ]B “F*& b˜C ]£C&* x£= “D3 ‡E Ÿ›’D œE*% H *]K / –˜gpE 9*xgA* “D3 (*
f£)¡~¦D* ,4b~7(°* *& b˜+ ŸF&* “DwC 9xgŒ- ]BH –m~z˜D* “D3 ¢D*( ¢g0 xƒ›- *& H2 f•~¦Œ˜D* “g€pE rbgŒE œ< kpc-
¡’£~6 ™žD f•+b˜D* f£)¡~¦D* ,4b~7(°* ¡D &° ¡Œ£~6 œJx1%°* œ£)b~zD* (bA ‡:bgD* 4¡c< “Fb’E(b+H $*x~¦1 ¢D(* hD¡p-

,4b~7°( * *¡D&° ¡žcg›J Ž¡~6 ™žF&b+ 9*xgA°* œE °K ]+ ™ž£•< f†Jx~6 ,xƒF ¤•- &* b˜K )*2 –~¦A°& * œE (* x˜0&°* ¡•D*