Page 319 - ibdaa
P. 319
-b<¡~9¡EH -bJxF *]+(°* 318
x~7bD* ~|D*
dJxmgD*
EXPERIMENT
i*4b£s+ bD ¤0¡J *& J ]£E g£- dJxmgD*H f~{D* H*& fDb& ~zD* xG¡/ ]J]p- ¤A dJxmgD* bF]<b~zJ &* J
"¡~zJH bJx+"H zAbsD* fBxAH "hJ*4" *¡1°& * A DwCH dJxmgD* E "¤~{£A*2 H24bF¡£D" 2bg~6* ]BH ,]J]/
bCH ¤Fb~zF(°* ~zmD* b~{g~6° qJx~{gD* ib£< E *2K ]< Ix/*& H $bD* ¢< "¤~{£A*2" exQ / ]D `:b~{D* 2°H*& H
rbJxD* bF*& ¢< e4bm- E bE b/ f£gD* ibE¡D* E x£cC 4*]E "hJ*4" J¡1°& * I]D
4¡J ]B F*& bC f£~8&*H ,]J]/ )*]+H 4bA*& ¢< xjJ ]B |s~{D* °& f£<*]+°( * 2¡mD* ¤A dJxmgD* Gb~zJ &* J
ib~9*xgA°*H £-HxD* ¢< bFK b£0&* H]gJ ]B $*xcsDbA ]0*H *% ¤A ]~9 H&* |s~{D* fp~|D J ]B D3 &* E ,xcsD*
f£<*]+°( * n)bgD* ¢< ~|pF pA |s~{D* + exQ mJ bE ¢< ]gJ D* E D £<]cE x£= Dw+ ¡F¡£A
4b~|cg~6°*H fDb~8&°* ¢D(* 2¡J &* gpJ bE ¡G D3 °& fJ]£gD* x£=H ,]J]mD* $b£~7&°* ¢< bcJxm- ¤A yCxF bC *3*(
¡- ]BH ib~zD* H&* ¤D* ¦BbgD* H*& bFK b£0*& ib~¦BbgD* ~7 fJ]£gD* x£=H ,]J]mD* $b£~7&°* wG w1b& -H ¤<*]+°( *
xD ,xjE ib/¡E wG
,x~7bcE 2¡- ° ]BH ,2]gE )*]+ xcgs- ]B e4bmgD* *& f£0 E D3 ngJH ¦BbgD* E $¤~{+ dJxmgD* c-xJH
4¡~{E x£= "¡gF¡£~6" ~8H b£~zD* *wG ¤A ÉK jE Eb& - bEK b- fDbA e4bmgD* H]c- ° ]B ¢D* *w+H ]0*H Q 0 ¢D(*
E ]0*H ¡F 2¡/H ~8¡D* *wG 9xgJH "fDbA x£=" bF&b+ "¡~6b£+" ]< f£D* f£D (Simonton, in press)
w+ J D "¡~6b£+" D pD* ¢D*( ,x~7bcE mgJH f~{D* fDb0 E x£~zJ ¥wD* ¤sD* ]gD* E ¡F ¡GH f£<bD*
hB¡D f£~¦E D3 *& "¡gF¡£~6" x~7 ]BH dJxmgD* $b.&* ¤A bAw0 bF*( H ¤)bD* n-bD* ¤A bK B x- DH ¡~6xD*
*xg<°* dmJH bpK /bFH °K bA bC "¡~6b£+" *& Ix1*& f/ E xJ ]0*& ° D fDbA f£< ~{J ° ]£Cb& gDb+ ¡GH ]mD*H
dgJ ]B *]+°( * D ¤)bD* n-bD* < ÉK £B -]+*& bF(*H bg~zJ D $b£~7*& obgF(° ££Ab~9(* ]/H hBH ¢D*( obg0* F&b+
J DH b~¦+ ¦A4H )*]cD* E x£jC ¤A kp+ F&° A ¤)bD* n-bD* E bK .*H "¡~6b£+" bC b+4H bFK b£0*& D3 C
)*]cD*H i*4b£sD* E ¦JxD* I]D* *wG ¤A xJ &* cB ¤)bD* n-bD* ¢D*( ¡~8¡D* ~6¡+
D f£gE b<K *¡F&* bD ngJ F&° bA 4¡gD* *wA x£gD* E ¡D* *wD °K ¡E *xK Jxc- ¤/¡D¡£cD* 4¡gD* bD xA¡JH
f£D* "¡~6b£+" e4bm- ¤A $*¡~6 2]gD* D $bcD* bE ,]J]< b~7&* £g~z- ° ]B 2]gD*H ¡gD* dg- 4¡gD* f£<
b~7*& ¤G i*4b£sD* E x£jC bC ¡D ¢g0 f~¦gD* ib£D* f£<bA E ]JyJH bK £E bAK ]G ]sJ ¤/¡D¡£cD* 4¡gD* ¤A &*
¤gD* f£D* ¢< pD ¤)bD* n-bD* bg~6* ~{JH ¤)bD* n-bD* ¢D*( ~8¡J ¥wD* sD* ¤A ,x~7bcE x£~z- °H ¡gD* E
¥]cD* x£gD* E ~7 f£D* ¢D(* ,2¡< n-bD* E x£gDbA Teleological fallacy f£)bD* ibDbD* I]0*( £D(* i2bB
*& bG fDbD* ¡gA b<&°* ¤A fBbpD*H dD* 4H2 < l]pgJ bE]< bK +b~{E *xK £- EbjD* ~|D* bD ~|J
bC b+4H fm£gF ¥&* ¢D(* ~8¡- ° ]B ¤gD* xJ¡gD*H kpcD*H e4bmgD 42b~|D* E *xK £jC 6xJ F&° bA x£= ¡J D*
|sgD*H 4bA&°* E x£cC 2]< obgF(* I¡~6 £< bE" bB bE]< fJ2]gD*H dJxmgDb+ xJ Linus pauling "nD¡+ 6¡£D"
"f_J2xD* 4bA°& * E